ICH Q10 describes two management reviews, in sections 3.2.4 and 4.1, and they look at different things.
The first has the product on the table. Management review should provide assurance that process performance and product quality are managed over the lifecycle. Inspection and audit results go in, with the periodic quality reviews, which can include complaints, monitoring conclusions and the effectiveness of changes.
Section 4.1 turns to the quality system itself. It expects a formal process, on a periodic basis, that measures whether the system's objectives were achieved and assesses indicators for its own processes, such as complaint, deviation, CAPA and change management.
On a plant, twelve deviations on one tablet line belong in the first review, and a median of 70 days to close any deviation belongs in the second.
The outcomes listed in section 4.3 can include improvements, allocation of resources or training, and escalation of appropriate issues to senior management.
Engineering data reaches the first review less often than it should. Requalification status, overdue calibrations and monitoring excursions are process performance.
Industries


