Skip to content

Life Sciences

Handling a deviation: secure the evidence in the first hour

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

An hour after a deviation is found, part of the evidence may already be gone.

The room has been cleaned and the operator has gone home. The controller's local trend may be overwritten within days. Whatever the investigation needs next week has to be secured now.

The 2013 text of EU GMP Chapter 1 lists among the basic requirements of GMP that any significant deviations are fully recorded and investigated with the objective of determining the root cause, and appropriate corrective and preventive action implemented. ICH Q10 adds that the effort and formality of the investigation should be commensurate with the level of risk. The sequence is left to the site, and site procedures usually come down to this:

  1. Record it when it is found, in the finder's own words, and contain it. Export the trend data and take photographs before anything is reset.
  2. Classify it by risk and list every batch, room and system that could be affected.
  3. Investigate the root cause with evidence. The same 2013 text says suspected human error should be justified, having taken care that process, procedural or system-based errors have not been overlooked.
  4. Set corrective and preventive actions, each with an owner and a date.
  5. Have QA review and close it, then trend it with the others.

A deviation form that opens with fields for "data exported from" and "photographs taken" produces better investigations than one that opens with the classification.

Topics

Industries

Related

More on this subject

HVAC changes and the repeat media fill

EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) lists significant modification to the HVAC system among the reasons to repeat an aseptic process simulation. Changes to airflow pattern, pressure regime or filter housings in aseptic areas should reach QA with an engineering note before the work, and the requalification should be planned with the shutdown.

InsightRead

Leave time between SOP approval and effective date

An SOP that becomes effective the moment it is signed puts the next shift in deviation before anyone is trained. The 2011 text of EU GMP Chapter 4 says the effective date should be defined; the gap after approval is where training, the swap of controlled copies and the register update take place.

InsightRead

MACO: from a health-based limit to a swab limit

MACO, the maximum allowable carryover, is the most of one product that may end up in a batch of the next. It is calculated from the previous product's PDE, the next product's smallest batch and its maximum daily dose, then divided over the shared equipment surface to give a limit per swab.

InsightRead