The signed autoclave chart went into the batch record this morning. The data file it was printed from never left the controller PC.
That is a hybrid system: a signed paper record with an electronic record behind it. The MHRA GxP data integrity guidance (2018) says that where hybrid systems are used, it should be clearly documented what constitutes the whole data set, and all records defined by the data set should be reviewed and retained. PIC/S PI 041-1 goes further: it says the use of hybrid systems is discouraged and such systems should be replaced whenever possible. Until that happens, the pair needs four controls in practice:
- A procedure names the whole data set for this system: which paper, which electronic files, which audit trail.
- The signed printout carries the file name and the system it came from. MHRA says references between physical and electronic records must be maintained throughout the retention period.
- The review record shows that the reviewer looked at the electronic data and its audit trail, as well as the printout.
- The printout has been shown to be complete, every cycle and every channel, and the file behind it is backed up and can still be opened.
Point 3 costs the most, because it puts a reviewer at the autoclave PC. It is also where a repeated cycle that was never printed gets found.
Industries



