Skip to content

Maintenance Service

Paper logbook or GMP CMMS: what makes either defensible

  • Maintenance Service
  • 1 min read

An inspector asks for two years of interventions on the filling-room AHU. With paper, that is a morning in the archive.

A paper maintenance logbook can be perfectly compliant. Bound, page-numbered, filled in with indelible ink, signed and dated at the time of the work, corrections struck through once and initialled. ALCOA+ does not require software. What paper struggles with is the rest of the job: linking the entry to the work order, the spare part used, the calibration certificate of the gauge, and the deviation raised when the filter ΔP was out of range. Those links live in someone's memory.

A GMP CMMS makes the links structural. The work order, the asset, the part and the result sit in one record, and the audit trail shows who changed what and when. Retrieval becomes a filter by asset and date.

The trade-off is that the software now has to be qualified. Annex 11 and 21 CFR Part 11 both expect access control. Part 11 (11.10(e)) requires secure, time-stamped audit trails, Annex 11 asks for one to be considered on risk, and MHRA and PIC/S data-integrity guidance adds that users must not be able to switch it off. Annex 11 also wants backups whose restore has been checked. An unvalidated CMMS with shared logins is weaker evidence than a good paper book.

We built a GMP CMMS for life-science maintenance for this reason: the maintenance record should be as defensible as the batch record.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

ALCOA+ on the EMS is a design requirement

Environmental monitoring and BMS data that support GMP decisions must meet ALCOA+. In practice that means individual logins, time-synchronized controllers, an audit trail users cannot disable, alarms acknowledged with name and comment, and tested backups, with GMP-critical parameters separated early onto a validated system.

Read

Part 11 starts with the predicate rule

Part 11 applies to electronic records that a predicate rule such as 21 CFR 211 requires. For a BMS or EMS, name the rule behind each point: GMP-critical monitoring usually belongs in a validated EMS. For EU export, Annex 11 has no predicate-rule test, so the BMS still needs a risk assessment.

InsightRead