Skip to content

Life Sciences

What a printed EMS trend leaves out

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

A printed EMS trend keeps one view of the data at one scale.

The raw values between the plotted points, the alarm acknowledgements and the audit trail stay behind in the system.

FDA's 2018 data integrity Q&A draws the line between static and dynamic records. A static record is fixed, like a paper page or a PDF image. A dynamic record allows the user to interact with its content: a chromatogram whose integration can be re-run is the textbook case, and an EMS trend with raw values, sensor quality flags and an audit trail behind it is another. The guidance says a printout generally cannot stand in for such a record, and PIC/S PI 041-1 takes the same line.

In practice that changes two things. The electronic original, with its audit trail, has to be kept for the full retention period in a form that can still be read and reprocessed, including after the EMS is upgraded or replaced. And the reviewer has to look at the data in the system, where an edited value or an acknowledged alarm shows up; a signature on a printout covers only what the printout shows.

Printouts still have a place, in a batch record or a shift handover. The SOP should call them convenience copies and say where the original is held.

In the URS we write for monitoring systems, we list which data are dynamic and where the original lives.

Does your EMS review SOP say whether the reviewer works on screen or on paper?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Annex 11: accuracy checks on manual entries

The 2011 text of EU GMP Annex 11 (clause 6) says that where critical data are entered manually there should be an additional check on their accuracy, by a second operator or by validated electronic means. For a BMS or EMS alarm limit, a permitted range on the field and a confirmation step are the practical answer.

InsightRead

CSV vs CSA on one BMS alarm function

Scripted CSV evidences every step of a BMS pressure alarm test. FDA's Computer Software Assurance guidance keeps scripted tests for high-risk checks such as setpoint, delay and the audit record, then adds unscripted testing of failure modes, recorded by what was tried and what happened.

InsightRead

GAMP 5 Second Edition (2022) scales validation effort to risk to patient safety, product quality and data integrity, and adds agile and cloud guidance. On a GMP BMS, test alarms, audit trail and data transfer deeply. A quick check: count low-risk functions that still carry full test scripts.

InsightRead