Skip to content

Life Sciences

Keep the BMS outside the EMS validation boundary

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Retuning a damper loop should take an afternoon. On a validated platform it takes a change request, an impact assessment and a test record.

That is the cost of running the building management system and the environmental monitoring system on one validated platform. The BMS runs fans, dampers, valves and schedules, and is retuned every season by the controls contractor. The EMS records the parameters that matter for product quality: room differential pressure, temperature, humidity, particle counts where fitted. Those are GMP records, so 21 CFR Part 11 and Annex 11 apply, with audit trail, access control and validated alarms.

On a shared platform the validation boundary has to go around the control logic too. Every setpoint change becomes a change-control item, and seasonal energy tuning quietly stops.

Our preference is an EMS with its own sensors on the critical parameters, its own database and its own alarms to QA, validated to its risk under GAMP 5. The BMS can then be managed under good engineering practice, and a controls technician can retune a loop without raising a change request.

The price is duplicated sensors and a second screen. On most GMP sites we would pay it.

Humiley designs automation and SCADA to Part 11 and Annex 11, and we would draw the validation boundary in the URS, before any platform is chosen.

How many BMS setpoint changes at your site went through change control last year?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GMP on the electrical side

Where a SCADA, BMS or EMS records GMP-relevant data, access control, clock synchronization, alarm records and audit trails are decided by the electrical and automation engineers. Many sites keep those parameters on a separate validated EMS. Humiley's cross-functional training covers GMP, validation and project management.

InsightRead

Servers, network, virtualisation, backup and time sync under a GMP system are qualified as a controlled platform; the application on top is validated for its intended use. With the platform qualified, a routine OS patch needs an impact assessment and a targeted check, not a new OQ of the SCADA.

InsightRead

Part 11 or Annex 11: fix the destination market on day one

21 CFR Part 11 and EU GMP Annex 11 overlap on validation, access control and audit trails but differ in emphasis: Part 11 on electronic signatures, Annex 11 on a risk-based system lifecycle. Fixing the destination market in the design basis means the URS and validation plan for BMS, EMS and SCADA are written once.

Read