Skip to content

News

The process around the FMEA in ICH Q9(R1)

  • News
  • 1 min read

FMEA is one tool. ICH Q9(R1) lists it among nine, inside a process that many risk files skip.

The usual file is a scored table with nothing before it and nothing after it. Section 4 of Q9(R1) sets out what should stand around that table, in a figure most of us have seen and few have followed line by line.

  1. Initiate. Possible steps, in Q9's words: define the problem or risk question with its assumptions, assemble background data, identify a leader, specify a timeline.
  2. Assess. Identify the hazards, analyse the risk, then evaluate it against given risk criteria. FMEA lives here.
  3. Control. Reduce the risk where it is above the acceptable level, then decide whether to accept what remains. Q9 notes that reduction measures can introduce new risks, so the assessment may need another pass.
  4. Communicate. The output of the process should be communicated and documented. Parties can communicate at any stage.
  5. Review. The results should be reviewed to take account of new knowledge and experience, after planned events such as an audit and unplanned ones such as a failure investigation. The frequency should be based on the level of risk.

A file that holds only step 2 answers a question nobody wrote down. The cheapest repair is a first page: the risk question, the assumptions and the date of the next review.

Related

More on this subject

What 21 CFR 11.10(e) asks of an EMS audit trail

21 CFR 11.10(e) requires secure, computer-generated, time-stamped audit trails. For an environmental monitoring system, that means the software logs setpoint, alarm-limit and user changes itself, nobody can purge entries, every clock follows one time source, and the requirements sit in the URS before a platform is chosen.

InsightRead

FDA's 2018 data integrity Q&A separates static records from dynamic ones. A printed EMS trend keeps one view and leaves raw values, metadata and the audit trail behind. Keep the electronic original for the retention period, have the reviewer work in the system, and label printouts as convenience copies.

InsightRead