A user ID and a green tick next to a batch step is not a Part 11 signature. It is missing two of the three things 21 CFR 11.50 asks for.
11.50(a) lists them as three numbered items. A signed electronic record must show:
(1) the printed name of the signer,
(2) the date and time the signature was executed,
(3) the meaning of the signature, such as review, approval, responsibility or authorship.
The user ID fails the first item, because an ID like "op0417" is not a printed name. The tick fails the third, because nobody reading the record later can tell whether that person reviewed the step, approved it or performed it. Only the timestamp usually survives.
11.50(b) adds the part that catches systems at audit: those items are under the same controls as the record and must appear in human-readable form, on screen and in any printout. A name that sits in a database table but never shows on the batch report does not meet it.
So when you test an e-signature in OQ, test the display and the printed report, not only the login prompt. Ask the vendor to show one signed record end to end, then change the signer's display name and see whether history changes with it. It should not.
Humiley designs automation and SCADA to 21 CFR Part 11 and Annex 11, with the signature manifestation written into the test scripts.
Industries



