Skip to content

Life Sciences

The receiving site validates the process again

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Ten years of batches at the sending site do not validate the process at the receiving site.

"The process is already validated" is heard in many transfer kick-off meetings. It was validated, at a site with different equipment, utilities, operators and procedures.

The WHO guideline on technology transfer (TRS 1044, Annex 4) leaves little room on who does the work. It defines validation batches as those produced by the receiving unit to demonstrate its ability to manufacture the transferred product.

EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) lists site transfers among the cases its process validation section covers. For a transferred product it says the number of validation batches could be reduced by a bracketing approach (testing only the extremes of factors such as strength or batch size), and that existing product knowledge, including the content of the previous validation, should be available.

Cleaning does not travel either. The WHO text says cleaning procedures and their validation should normally be site specific.

The sending unit's validation report therefore goes into the transfer package as an input: it supports the design of the receiving unit's protocol and gives the new results a baseline.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GEP: what qualification can rely on, and what it repeats

Good engineering practice is the design review, installation checks and commissioning that sit under qualification. WHO's HVAC guideline defines it, and EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) allows data from outside the manufacturer's own programs if justified and controlled. Commissioning sheets made with calibrated instruments and signed by the person who measured can then be relied on.

InsightRead

Qualification comes before the registration batches

On the road to registration, facility, utility and equipment qualification sits before the registration batches: fix products and markets in the design basis, qualify, make the batches on qualified equipment, run stability and submit. Where process validation and the inspection fall depends on the region and the process. A delay in PQ moves the earliest submission date.

InsightRead

The room data sheet changes jobs at qualification

A room data sheet begins as a design input that changes weekly and ends as the qualified record behind OQ, PQ and monitoring limits. Each role needs different revision control. Agree the freeze point before DQ, so design and QA are never editing different versions of the same room.

InsightRead