Say a batch ends at 22:00 and the vessel is cleaned at 09:00: eleven hours of dirty hold against a validated eight is a deviation.
EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says the time between manufacture and cleaning, and between cleaning and use, should be taken into account to define dirty and clean hold times. It is the cleaning validation point production planning has to live with: a late shift or a long weekend breaks it without any change to the procedure.
Four more points in section 10 of the 2015 text shape the protocol, all written with "should".
Cleaning validation should confirm the effectiveness of any cleaning procedure for all product contact equipment. Where similar equipment is grouped, a justification of the equipment selected is expected, so the grouping rationale has to exist on paper.
Limits for the carryover of product residues should be based on a toxicological evaluation; the annex points to the EMA guideline on health-based exposure limits. A limit with no toxicology behind it is hard to defend against that sentence.
Where cleaning is ineffective or not appropriate for some equipment, dedicated equipment or other appropriate measures should be used. Where cleaning is manual, its effectiveness should be confirmed at a justified frequency.
The validated hold times belong on the production schedule as well as in the validation report, because the planner is the one who can prevent the eleven hours.
Industries




