On many projects OQ repeats airflow readings that commissioning took weeks before, because QA will not rely on the sheets.
Good engineering practice, GEP, covers the work underneath both: design review, installation checks, pressure tests, loop checks, balancing. The glossary of WHO's HVAC guideline defines it as established engineering methods and standards that are applied throughout the project life cycle to deliver appropriate, cost-effective solutions.
The same guideline sorts systems by impact: direct impact systems are designed and commissioned in line with GEP and are also qualified, while indirect and no-impact systems get GEP only.
How far qualification can lean on that commissioning is decided by the paper. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says data obtained from sources outside the manufacturer's own programs may be used, provided the approach has been justified and there is adequate assurance that controls were in place while the data were acquired. In practice: calibrated instruments, an approved procedure, and sheets signed and dated by whoever took the reading.
A balancing report with no instrument serial numbers cannot be relied on, and the airflow gets measured again in OQ.
Industries




