Skip to content

Life Sciences

An audit trail that keeps only the new value fails Part 11

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

A room pressure setpoint goes from 15 Pa to 12 Pa. The SCADA log records the user, the time and 12 Pa. The 15 is gone.

That log fails 21 CFR 11.10(e) on one phrase: record changes shall not obscure previously recorded information. An audit trail that keeps only the new value tells an inspector that something changed and hides what it changed from. For a GMP parameter, the old value is exactly what they want to see.

The same clause asks for secure, computer-generated, time-stamped audit trails that independently record operator entries and actions that create, modify or delete electronic records, kept for at least as long as the records themselves. Three tests we would run on any BMS, EMS or SCADA before OQ:

  1. Change a GMP setpoint and read the trail. Old value, new value, user, date and time should all be there.
  2. Try to edit or delete a trail entry with administrator rights. The system should refuse, or record the attempt.
  3. Compare how long the trail is kept with the retention period of the batch records it supports.

EU GMP Annex 11 also expects the reason for a GMP-relevant change to be documented, so a system sold into both markets needs a reason field as well.

Humiley designs automation and SCADA to 21 CFR Part 11 and Annex 11. Writing the audit trail into the URS costs far less than adding it after FAT.

Talk to an engineer: contact@humiley.com, +84 28 7777 6668 (Viet Nam office).

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GMP on the electrical side

Where a SCADA, BMS or EMS records GMP-relevant data, access control, clock synchronization, alarm records and audit trails are decided by the electrical and automation engineers. Many sites keep those parameters on a separate validated EMS. Humiley's cross-functional training covers GMP, validation and project management.

InsightRead

GAMP 5 Second Edition puts critical thinking first

GAMP 5 Second Edition (2022) scales validation effort to risk to patient safety, product quality and data integrity, and adds agile and cloud guidance. On a GMP BMS, test alarms, audit trail and data transfer deeply. A quick check: count low-risk functions that still carry full test scripts.

InsightRead

Keep the BMS outside the EMS validation boundary

When the BMS and the validated EMS share one platform, the validation boundary takes in the control logic and every setpoint change becomes change control. An EMS with its own sensors, database and QA alarms under Part 11 and Annex 11 allows the BMS to be managed under good engineering practice.

InsightRead