Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

Value engineering after tender: savings that return at OQ

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

When a cleanroom HVAC tender comes in over budget, the value-engineering list that follows tends to carry the same three lines.

  1. The AHU casing drops from EN 1886 leakage class L1 to L2. On paper that is a cheaper panel and fewer sealing details. In the plant, sections under negative pressure pull in unfiltered plant-room air, and sections under positive pressure lose air the fan has already paid to move and cool. The airflow reaching the rooms falls short of what the calculation assumed.
  2. Room pressure transmitters are cut from one per room pair to one per zone. The BMS drawings look tidier. Then OQ has to demonstrate the cascade and its alarms room by room, and for the rooms without a sensor that means hand-held readings and a deviation about continuous monitoring.
  3. Door drop-seals come off the door schedule and the ceiling grid gasket changes to a cheaper type. Envelope leakage goes up, the airflow offset sized for the old gaps no longer holds 10 Pa, and the pressure test fails on the rooms with the most doors.

Any of these can be the right call on a given project, provided someone has checked it against the URS line and the OQ test it touches before the saving is accepted. We keep every design decision traceable from requirement to calculation, drawing and test, which is the record that check needs.

Which value-engineering saving has cost you most at qualification?

Related

More on this subject

Three APS runs across all shifts, and the HVAC has to hold still

Annex 1 initial validation of an aseptic process needs at least 3 consecutive successful simulations covering all working shifts, then periodic runs twice a year per process, line and shift. The cleanroom must hold its qualified state throughout. Agree an HVAC freeze date with QA, and list in advance which jobs are like-for-like and which need an impact assessment.

InsightRead