Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

Owner-written or designer-drafted: who should write the URS

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

Design qualification checks the design against the URS. When the designer wrote the URS, DQ is the designer checking their own work.

That happens more often than people admit. The owner is busy, the designer has the room data sheets open anyway, and a draft URS arrives that describes, quite accurately, the system already on the drawings. Every line passes DQ, because none of them was ever at risk.

An owner-written URS reads differently. It is rougher, it has gaps an engineer would fill, and some lines are wishes. But it states what the process needs in the owner's words: batch sizes, open and closed steps, cleaning agents, the hours the rooms run, the market the product goes to. When the design meets that document, DQ has tested something.

The useful split is by content, whoever holds the pen. The owner's process, QA and production people own every requirement and sign each line. The designer can draft wording, add numbers the owner cannot know yet, and flag lines no test could fail. A requirement written to fit a solution already chosen should never get through.

Humiley writes URS and validation strategy in parallel with the design, which is exactly the case where that line needs watching, so the owner's QA should challenge our draft before it is frozen.

On your last project, whose name was on the URS approval page?

Related

More on this subject

PIC/S GMP and EU GMP: who issues the certificate

The PIC/S GMP Guide and EU GMP are almost identical, revised Annex 1 included. In the EU the GMP principles are set in law and certificates sit in EudraGMDP; PIC/S authorities adopt the guide nationally and PIC/S certifies nothing. One design serves both; the EU inspection route is planned separately.

InsightRead