Skip to content

News

Measuring a pressure cascade: where the error hides

  • News
  • 1 min read

Three rooms in a cascade, each pressure sensor good to ±1 Pa.

Measured room to room, the innermost room against the corridor carries up to ±3 Pa of error.

A pressure cascade can be measured two ways, and each one hides its error in a different place.

The first puts every room against one common reference, usually the corridor or a point outside the suite. Errors do not stack, since each reading carries one sensor's error. The catch is the difference between two adjacent rooms, which has to be computed from two readings and so carries up to ±2 Pa. Against a 10 Pa design differential, that is a fifth of the value.

Direct sensors across each door give you the differential that sets airflow direction between rooms, which is what Annex 1 expects to be monitored, with one sensor's error on it. The weak point moves to the end of the chain: the innermost room against the reference is a sum of readings, and the errors add up with it.

Neither scheme is wrong. A good system records one set, computes the other, and states the error budget for both, so no alarm limit is set tighter than the measurement can resolve.

The scheme belongs in the design basis beside the setpoints, where the BMS engineer and the validation team read the same numbers. Humiley designs cleanroom pressure cascades for Grade A to D suites.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Value engineering after tender: savings that return at OQ

After an over-budget cleanroom HVAC tender, three savings recur: an EN 1886 L2 casing instead of L1, fewer room pressure transmitters, and deleted door drop-seals. Each can reappear as an OQ failure in airflow, alarm testing or pressure differentials, so check every line against its URS requirement and test before accepting it.

InsightRead

WFI belongs in the Contamination Control Strategy

EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) gives WFI circulation above 70 °C as an example of minimizing the risk of microbial growth. Keeping a loop hot drives the design: ASME BPE dead legs of L/D ≤ 2, turbulent flow to the last user point, planned sanitization and sensors on the return. The CCS should justify all of it.

InsightRead