Skip to content

Life Sciences

What an audit trail review actually looks for

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

"Audit trail reviewed" is a tick box on many batch record checklists, and few reviewers could tell you what they looked for.

Annex 11 asks for audit trails of GMP-relevant changes and deletions, and for them to be regularly reviewed. FDA's data integrity guidance expects the audit trail behind critical data to be reviewed before the record is approved. Neither document gives the reviewer a list, so the site has to write one.

On an EMS or a BMS, these are the events worth filtering for.

  1. Deleted or overwritten data. Who, when, and whether a reason was recorded.
  2. Setpoint and alarm limit changes. Each should match an approved change control; one that doesn't is a finding on its own.
  3. Alarms acknowledged with no comment, especially the same alarm acknowledged by the same user many times in a shift.
  4. Repeated tests or reprocessed results before a passing one. A pressure hold rerun three times looks very different in the trail than in the report.
  5. System clock changes and user or role changes, which make every other entry harder to trust.

Written this way, a reviewer can filter the trail by event type, work through five queries and sign for what they checked. It also tells the system owner which reports the software has to produce, which is worth knowing before the URS is signed.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GAMP 5 Second Edition (2022) scales validation effort to risk to patient safety, product quality and data integrity, and adds agile and cloud guidance. On a GMP BMS, test alarms, audit trail and data transfer deeply. A quick check: count low-risk functions that still carry full test scripts.

InsightRead

Metadata: what a stored value needs to mean anything

A stored value of 22.4 means nothing without its sensor tag, unit, time stamp, status flag, author and audit trail. The MHRA's 2018 data integrity guidance defines metadata as data that describe the attributes of other data and provide context and meaning. Test that backups, exports and migrations carry them.

InsightRead

Part 11 starts with the predicate rule

Part 11 applies to electronic records that a predicate rule such as 21 CFR 211 requires. For a BMS or EMS, name the rule behind each point: GMP-critical monitoring usually belongs in a validated EMS. For EU export, Annex 11 has no predicate-rule test, so the BMS still needs a risk assessment.

InsightRead