Skip to content

News

A change is closed by data, not by installation

  • News
  • 1 min read

Plenty of change records close on the day the new equipment is installed. ICH Q10 asks for one more step.

Its change management section expects an evaluation after implementation, to confirm the change achieved what it was meant to and did no harm to product quality. Installing the part is only the start of that.

Take a common one. A room has had humidity excursions every wet season, so the change replaces the dehumidifier controller. The controller goes in on a Friday, the SAT passes, and the change is closed the same afternoon. Nobody writes down what "fixed" would look like, so when the wet season arrives and the excursions come back at a lower rate, there is no agreed way to say whether the change worked.

The fix is to write the effectiveness check when the change is approved:

what data will show the objective was met (excursion count, trend of the room RH);

over what period, long enough to include the conditions that caused the problem;

and what result closes the change, or reopens it.

Written after the fact, the check tends to become "no complaints received".

Our maintenance service runs condition monitoring and trending on the systems we look after, and that trend data is what an effectiveness check on an HVAC change usually needs.

How long does your site wait before judging an HVAC change effective?

Related

More on this subject

Compare deliverable lists before you compare totals

Two engineering proposals with similar totals can cover very different scopes. Before comparing prices, check that each deliverable list names Room Data Sheets, the pressure cascade and airflow balance, the URS and qualification protocols, the FAT and equipment file, and an asset register behind maintenance response times.

InsightRead

Engineering's part of the product quality review

The 2013 text of EU GMP Chapter 1 lists the qualification status of relevant equipment and utilities among the items a product quality review should include. Engineering can make that line believable with four more inputs: changes in the period, excursions and trends, calibration and maintenance failures with product impact, and the status of engineering CAPAs.

InsightRead