Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

Compare deliverable lists before you compare totals

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

Two engineering proposals for the same GMP suite can carry similar totals and very different scopes.

The difference usually sits in the deliverable list. Often one proposal names every document and the other says "HVAC design", leaving the rest to be found after award, as a variation.

Before comparing totals, put the deliverable lists side by side and check that each one names:

  1. Room Data Sheets for every room: grade, temperature and RH ranges, pressure to each neighbour.
  2. The pressure cascade drawing and the airflow and pressure balance behind it.
  3. The URS, the validation strategy and the qualification protocols. "By others" on any of them means someone still has to write it, and pay for it.
  4. For equipment, the FAT and the equipment file (material certificates, FAT report, O&M manuals, spares), so IQ does not start from a missing record.
  5. For maintenance, an asset register with a criticality assessment behind the response times.

A line present in one list and missing from the other is worth a question to both bidders before anyone looks at the price.

On our projects the URS, validation strategy and qualification roadmap are written in parallel with the design, so they sit on the deliverable list from the first issue.

Talk to an engineer: contact@humiley.com · +84 28 7777 6668 (Viet Nam office)

Related

More on this subject

Three APS runs across all shifts, and the HVAC has to hold still

Annex 1 initial validation of an aseptic process needs at least 3 consecutive successful simulations covering all working shifts, then periodic runs twice a year per process, line and shift. The cleanroom must hold its qualified state throughout. Agree an HVAC freeze date with QA, and list in advance which jobs are like-for-like and which need an impact assessment.

InsightRead

Annex 1 has applied since 25 August 2023

The revised EU GMP Annex 1 has applied since 25 August 2023, with point 8.123 following in 2024. A site still planning its gap assessment is years behind. Most findings land in the CCS, for example a pressure alarm delay set at commissioning that nobody can justify.

InsightRead

Central Vacuum Cleaning

In GMP audits, scrutiny often lands on Cleaning Procedures. Using portable vacuum cleaners in cleanrooms is a red flag. Why? Because the exhaust turbulence from a portable unit disrupts laminar airflow and can aerosolize settled dust,…

InsightRead