Skip to content

News

Calibrate the energy model before claiming savings

  • News
  • 1 min read

Before an energy model justifies a retrofit, it should match the plant's meters: ±5% NMBE and 15% CV(RMSE) on monthly data.

The usual bar is ASHRAE Guideline 14. Against monthly data, a model counts as calibrated when its normalised mean bias error (NMBE) is within ±5% and its coefficient of variation of the root mean square error, CV(RMSE), is within 15%. Against hourly data the limits are ±10% and 30%.

The two numbers catch different faults. NMBE is net bias: a model can hit the annual total by being 20% high in the dry season and 20% low in the wet season, and NMBE alone will not notice. CV(RMSE) measures the month-by-month scatter, where the seasons show. In a tropical plant the wet season is usually the one a model gets wrong, because dehumidification and reheat are easy to underestimate.

This matters before a retrofit because the savings you claim are the difference between two model runs. If the baseline run does not match the meters, the difference is a guess with decimals.

In practice that means 12 months of metered data per system, not only the site bill; submeters on the chillers and large AHUs; real schedules and setpoints; and a monthly comparison before anyone looks at options.

Our energy modeling targets a 30% reduction in HVAC energy, and a target like that means little without a calibrated baseline. To talk it through: contact@humiley.com or +84 28 7777 6668 (Viet Nam office).

Related

More on this subject

Checks that make a URS line testable

A URS line such as 'the HVAC system shall maintain suitable conditions' cannot be tested. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says the URS should be a point of reference throughout the validation life cycle. Five checks make a line usable: one requirement, a unique ID, a number with unit and tolerance, the state, and a named test.

InsightRead

CTD Module 3 describes the plant you are building

The CTD has five modules, and Module 3 (Quality) records the process, its controls and often the facility, including room grades, water grades and the conditions behind hold times. After approval, changing them generally needs a variation. Draft Module 3 and the design basis from one table and send every change to both teams.

InsightRead