"The HVAC system shall maintain suitable conditions" is a URS line that no test can fail.
A line no test can fail gives PQ nothing to prove. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says the specification should be defined in a URS and/or a functional specification, that the URS should be a point of reference throughout the validation life cycle, and that its requirements should be verified during design qualification. A reference only works if each line can be checked. The annex does not say how to write one; the five checks below are ours.
Take any line and check:
- It holds one requirement. "Temperature and humidity shall be controlled and alarmed" holds four.
- It has a unique ID that the DQ and the test protocols can cite.
- It carries a number, a unit and a tolerance, such as 22 °C ± 2 °C.
- It names the state it applies in, at rest or in operation, and the rooms.
- You can name the test that proves it, and the instrument.
Rewritten, the opening line becomes several, each like this: "URS-HV-012: Room 105 shall be held at 22 °C ± 2 °C in operation, measured at the return grille."
Lines that cannot name their test are often design wishes. They belong in the basis of design, where no test has to prove them.
We write the URS, the validation strategy and the qualification roadmap in parallel with the design.
Could you name the test for line 12 of your URS without opening the protocol?
Industries



