Skip to content

Life Sciences

Comparative method transfer: where the criteria come from

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

When two laboratories compare assay results in a method transfer, the allowed difference should come from the method's validation study.

EU GMP Chapter 6 says the transfer of a testing method should be described in a detailed protocol, and that its acceptance criteria should be based upon the current validation study of the methodology. Say the two assay means differ by 0.8%. Whether that is close enough depends on the precision the validation study found, and a limit borrowed from another product's protocol answers a different question.

In order:

  1. Write the protocol, with the experimental design, the acceptance criteria and the handling of deviations. The receiving unit should formally agree the acceptance criteria before execution.
  2. Train the receiving analysts. Check that instruments are qualified and that columns, reagents and reference standards match.
  3. Test the same homogeneous lots in both laboratories, with the number of analysts defined and justified.
  4. Compare the results against the criteria and report. Deviations from the protocol should be investigated before the transfer is closed; then the receiving laboratory is approved for the method.

WHO's technology transfer guideline lists this route, comparability testing between the two units, as one of several ways to transfer an analytical procedure and says the choice should be risk based; USP <1224> calls it comparative testing.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

GEP: what qualification can rely on, and what it repeats

Good engineering practice is the design review, installation checks and commissioning that sit under qualification. WHO's HVAC guideline defines it, and EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) allows data from outside the manufacturer's own programs if justified and controlled. Commissioning sheets made with calibrated instruments and signed by the person who measured can then be relied on.

InsightRead