Skip to content

Life Sciences

Cleaning validation: five steps, and sampling is the fourth

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Swabs are step four of a cleaning validation. Most arguments over a swab result were settled, or not, in steps one to three.

The sequence below follows section 10 of EU GMP Annex 15 (2015 text).

  1. Choose the worst case. Where a worst-case product is the model, the Annex says a scientific rationale should be provided for the choice; solubility, cleanability, toxicity and potency are criteria it may rest on.
  2. Set the limit. Carryover limits should be based on a toxicological evaluation, and the Annex points to the EMA guideline on health-based exposure limits.
  3. Fix where and how to sample. The protocol should specify the locations and the reason for each. Recovery should be shown to be possible from every product-contact material sampled, with every sampling method used.
  4. Run it. The time before cleaning and the time before next use should be taken into account to define dirty and clean hold times, and the number of runs should rest on a risk assessment.
  5. Report, then keep confirming. For manual cleaning the Annex says effectiveness should be confirmed at a justified frequency.

On the limit itself, the EMA Q&A of 2018 says the guideline is not intended to be used to set cleaning limits at the level of the calculated exposure limit. We read that figure as the ceiling, with the working limit below it.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Cpk 1.33: a convention, and what the GMP texts say instead

A Cpk of 1.33 puts the nearer specification limit 4 standard deviations from the process mean. It is a statistical convention: EU GMP Annex 15 (2015 text) and the FDA guidance of 2011 recommend statistical tools and name no index. With 10 batches the confidence interval is wide, so report the batch count and the interval.

InsightRead

CPV: one abbreviation, two different things

Continued process verification is the FDA's Stage 3: assurance during routine production that the process remains in a state of control. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) calls it ongoing process verification. Continuous process verification, defined in ICH Q8(R2), is an alternative approach to validation. Write the phrase out and cite its source.

InsightRead

CTD Module 3 describes the plant you are building

The CTD has five modules, and Module 3 (Quality) records the process, its controls and often the facility, including room grades, water grades and the conditions behind hold times. After approval, changing them generally needs a variation. Draft Module 3 and the design basis from one table and send every change to both teams.

InsightRead