Skip to content

Life Sciences

Why two teams give the same failure mode 40 and 160

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Two teams scored the same failure mode. One wrote 40 on the FMEA sheet, the other 160.

The failure mode was a leaking gasket on a terminal HEPA housing. The engineering team gave severity 5, occurrence 2, detection 4. A second team, with QA and microbiology in the room, gave 8, 4 and 5. No single score moved by more than three points on a ten-point scale, and the product moved by a factor of four. The scores are invented for the example.

Neither team was careless. The first knew the housing had passed its last leak test. The second knew what had grown on a settle plate in that room.

A risk priority number looks like a measurement because it is a number. It is three judgements on ranked scales, multiplied. The ranks are ordinal, so 160 does not mean four times the risk of 40.

ICH Q9(R1) gave the subject a section of its own. It says subjectivity can be introduced when risk questions are inadequately defined and when tools have poorly designed scoring scales, that it cannot be completely eliminated, and that it may be controlled by addressing bias and assumptions, using the tools properly and maximizing the use of relevant data and sources of knowledge.

On a scoring sheet that comes down to anchoring each scale step to something countable and writing the assumptions beside the score.

What does a 4 for occurrence mean on your site's scale, in events per year?

Topics

Industries

Related

More on this subject

AHU casing deflection: D1 or D2

EN 1886 classes AHU casing strength by deflection at test pressure: D1 up to 4 mm/m, D2 up to 10 mm/m. On a high-static GMP supply unit, a flexing panel works its gaskets loose and leakage rises. Ask which class was tested, on what model box, and whether your design pressure fits.

InsightRead

An SOP register answers the change-control question

An SOP register should record, for each SOP, the owner, version, review date and every document it refers to. Humiley's template covers 536 SOPs across 20 departments. The cross-reference column tells a change control which documents a revision touches, and review dates keep superseded versions out of use.

InsightRead

Both states are required; only the stage is a choice

A 50 m² Grade B room needs 10 classification locations under ISO 14644-1:2015, and EU GMP Annex 1 requires them at rest against ISO 5 and in operation against ISO 7, with the smoke study in both states. Whether each run sits in OQ or PQ is for the URS and risk assessment to justify.

InsightRead