Skip to content

Life Sciences

Impact assessment: where qualification effort goes

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

The chiller plant that feeds a Grade B air handler is the system impact assessments argue about longest.

The ISPE Baseline Guide Volume 5, first edition 2001, sorts systems three ways. A direct impact system affects product quality: the AHU serving a Grade B room, where supply air, filtration and pressure are part of the product's environment. An indirect impact system supports a direct one without touching the product, which often describes the chiller plant feeding that AHU's coil. Office ventilation, with no effect on either, is no impact.

Each class carries different evidence. Direct impact systems go through IQ, OQ and PQ with QA approval of each protocol. Indirect impact systems are commissioned under good engineering practice, with records that support the direct system's qualification. No impact systems are handed over like any building system.

If the AHU controls supply temperature and humidity and alarms when it cannot hold them, the chiller can stay indirect, because its failure shows up as an alarm on a qualified system. If a chiller failure can drift room conditions without any alarm, the classification deserves a second look.

The 2019 second edition moved the focus to critical aspects and critical design elements. Many sites still use the 2001 triage as a first cut.

We write the impact assessment with the URS, so the classification is settled before the protocols are.

Where does your team draw the line for chilled water?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Before changing an inherited facility or design, a written gap assessment against the URS and target regulations gives management and inspectors the same picture: evidence from documents and spot measurements, findings graded by risk, and the fix, cost range and schedule impact of each, plus what can stay.

InsightRead

EU GMP Chapter 4 expects logbooks for major or critical equipment, recording use, calibration, maintenance, cleaning and repairs with dates and names. For an AHU serving graded rooms that means qualification events, sensor calibration, filter changes with differential pressure, repairs with deviation numbers and cleaning records.

InsightRead