Skip to content

Life Sciences

Scale-up is more than a bigger batch size

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Five times the batch, the same set-points on the recipe screen, and the granules come out different.

A batch record lists set-points; it does not say which of them depend on scale. Impeller speed is the plain case: at the same rpm a wider bowl has a higher tip speed, so the wet mass is worked harder. A deeper bed in the fluid-bed dryer sees the same inlet temperature and a different drying curve. The sending site usually knows which ones from development.

WHO's technology transfer guideline (TRS 1044, Annex 4) treats batch size as a risk question. Production volumes and batch sizes at the sending and receiving units should be compared, and where they differ, the impact should be assessed as part of the risk assessment. The two sites' equipment should be compared for working principle, capacity, make and model. FDA's SUPAC guidance for immediate-release solid dosage forms builds its batch-size levels on the same condition: equipment of the same design and operating principles.

The building scales too. Five times the batch means more dust at charging, more exhaust air and moisture from a larger dryer, more purified water. A suite that held its pressures and humidity with the old dryer can run short of exhaust and make-up air with the new one.

Trial batches at the new scale settle the set-points; the validation batches then confirm them.

Which parameter moved most the last time you scaled up a granulation?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Taking over a facility: start with a written gap assessment

Before changing an inherited facility or design, a written gap assessment against the URS and target regulations gives management and inspectors the same picture: evidence from documents and spot measurements, findings graded by risk, and the fix, cost range and schedule impact of each, plus what can stay.

InsightRead

Zero growth and the HVAC record around a media fill

Annex 1 sets zero growth as the APS target, and any contaminated unit fails it. The environmental side of the investigation starts from viable monitoring, with HVAC and EMS trends as support, so review trends before the fill, confirm logging and clock sync, and agree which HVAC events count as interruptions.

InsightRead

Checks that make a URS line testable

A URS line such as 'the HVAC system shall maintain suitable conditions' cannot be tested. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says the URS should be a point of reference throughout the validation life cycle. Five checks make a line usable: one requirement, a unique ID, a number with unit and tolerance, the state, and a named test.

InsightRead