Chilled water that flows backwards through a decoupler reaches the fresh-air coil warmer than any chiller made it.
That is the failure to watch in a primary-secondary system. Constant-speed primary pumps push a fixed flow through each running chiller. Variable-speed secondary pumps send the coils what they ask for. The decoupler pipe between the two loops carries the difference. When the coils want more than the chillers circulate, return water runs back through the decoupler and mixes into the supply. On a GMP site, that mixed water feeds the coil that sets the room dew point.
Variable-primary drops one set of pumps. The same variable-speed pumps run through the chillers and out to the coils, so pump energy falls and there is no constant primary flow to pay for at night. The price is control. Each chiller has a minimum evaporator flow set by its manufacturer, so the system needs a bypass valve and a flow meter to hold it, and staging a chiller on or off causes a flow swing that can trip a machine.
Our view for a GMP plant: variable-primary is worth it when the controls contractor has done it before and the sequence is proved at commissioning with a chiller actually staging. Otherwise primary-secondary, with a flow meter in the decoupler and an alarm on reverse flow, is the safer trade.
Industries




