"Like-for-like" on a change request is a conclusion. In a validated suite it needs measured evidence before anything is fabricated.
A replacement fan, FFU or AHU is like-for-like only if it matches the installed item on every parameter the qualification relied on. The label is tempting because it keeps the change small, so it often goes on the form before anyone has checked.
The comparison needs data taken from the installed item, rather than copied from the original schedule:
- The real duty point: airflow and static pressure where the old unit actually ran.
- Filter classes, frame types and seal details.
- Connection dimensions, weight and service clearances.
- Control points, alarm set points and how the BMS or EMS reads them.
- Materials and finishes on any surface inside the clean zone.
Where the new item differs, write each difference down and assess it. One documented difference is a small, controlled change. Several discovered after delivery turn a replacement into a redesign, with the requalification that goes with it.
The decision belongs to QA, made in the change control before fabrication starts, with the survey data attached. Treat the old drawing as the starting point for that survey. After years of modifications it is rarely the whole truth.




