Skip to content

News

What a smoke study proves, and what it does not

  • News
  • 1 min read

The smoke leaves the filter, sweeps past the filling needles and out under the barrier, and everyone watching nods.

The video has proved less than the nodding suggests. Airflow visualization is persuasive, and easy to over-read.

What a well-run smoke study does show:

  • The airflow pattern over the critical zone: unidirectional flow reaching exposed product without turbulence or reverse flow.
  • That air moves from clean to less clean at openings, barrier doors and mouse holes.
  • How interventions disturb the flow, if operators perform them during the study with the real equipment in place.

What it does not show:

  • Particle levels or filter integrity. A tidy pattern can sit under a leaking filter; that is what the installed leak test and classification are for.
  • Velocity. Smoke shows direction, not whether the flow meets its specified velocity.
  • Microbial control, cleaning effectiveness or gowning discipline.
  • In-operation behaviour, if the study was filmed at rest with the line empty.

Annex 1 (2022) asks for airflow pattern studies both at rest and in operation, with operator interventions simulated. The value comes from planning: which interventions, which camera angles and which acceptance criteria, agreed before the smoke generator is switched on.

Who agreed the intervention list for your last smoke study?

Topics

Related

More on this subject

What ends the life of a HEPA filter

EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) asks for an integrity test of final filters at requalification and puts no age on the filter. A terminal HEPA is replaced when a leak cannot be repaired within site limits, when pressure drop reaches the manufacturer's final value, or after damage or wetting. On glass-fibre media, dust loading alone does not lower efficiency.

InsightRead

When gowning fails, walk the change room

Annex 1 expects Grade A/B staff to be reassessed for gowning at least annually. When the same people keep failing, check the change room before retraining: a clear dirty/clean line, space to gown, stations in SOP order, and a final stage at the grade of the room it serves.

InsightRead