Skip to content

News

One test for commissioning and qualification

  • News
  • 1 min read

The same airflow balance gets tested twice on many projects: once by the commissioning team, again by the qualification team a month later.

The two activities answer different questions. Commissioning is good engineering practice, owned by engineering: does the system work as designed? Qualification is documented evidence, approved by QA, that the aspects critical to product quality and patient safety meet their requirements.

ISPE's Baseline Guide Volume 5 (second edition, 2019) and ASTM E2500 both allow a commissioning test to serve as qualification evidence. The condition is how it was run, not who ran it. To count, the test must be on a critical aspect identified in advance, run to an approved protocol with acceptance criteria, with calibrated instruments, recorded as it happened, and with deviations handled. QA does not have to witness everything, but it has to have agreed that the test would count before it was run.

Miss any of those and the result is good engineering data that QA cannot sign. Then the test is repeated, the schedule slips, and nobody learns anything new from the second run.

In our EPCM work, commissioning and qualification plans are written together, so the critical tests are identified early and run once.

On your last project, how many commissioning tests could QA actually accept?

Related

More on this subject

Two envelopes for a cleanroom HVAC tender

Score the technical envelope of a cleanroom HVAC tender and sign it off before any price is opened. Issue the scoring sheet with the tender: mandatory items pass or fail, the rest weighted, for example 40% technical depth and 20% each for documentation, delivery and service. Score every listed deviation.

InsightRead

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

When the design exists: what EPCM takes on

Owners holding a finished design need someone to run the build against it, while the design stays with the designer of record. Design gaps are best listed at the first stage gate in five columns: the drawing, what is missing, the activity blocked, who closes it, and a date taken from the blocked activity's schedule.

InsightRead