Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

Who witnesses commissioning, and what QA can rely on

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

The contractor who installed the ductwork usually reports that it is balanced. That is the case for paying someone else to watch.

Self-commissioning is the cheaper route and not a careless one. The installer knows the system, has people on site, and is bound by contract to hand over a working plant. What it cannot offer is distance. Its team is checking its own work, often in the weeks before its retention is released, and a marginal reading tends to get one more adjustment and a pass.

An independent commissioning agent works for the owner. It reviews the design for testability, writes or approves the procedures, witnesses the tests and owns the issues log, so an issue stays open until the owner closes it. The fee is real. A good agent also slows the job down, at exactly the points where it should.

QA does not need independence on every test. It needs it on the results it will lean on later: the room pressure cascade, airflow and air change rates in classified rooms, HEPA installed leak tests, alarms and interlocks. For those, a witness who is not paid by the installer, calibrated instruments and an approved procedure turn a commissioning sheet into evidence. The rest can be self-commissioned and spot-checked.

In our EPCM role we sit on the owner's side of the witness table, from FAT and SAT through commissioning and qualification.

Which tests on your last project did someone independent actually witness?

Related

More on this subject

The revised EU GMP Annex 1 has applied since 25 August 2023, with point 8.123 following in 2024. A site still planning its gap assessment is years behind. Most findings land in the CCS, for example a pressure alarm delay set at commissioning that nobody can justify.

InsightRead

Both states are required; only the stage is a choice

A 50 m² Grade B room needs 10 classification locations under ISO 14644-1:2015, and EU GMP Annex 1 requires them at rest against ISO 5 and in operation against ISO 7, with the smoke study in both states. Whether each run sits in OQ or PQ is for the URS and risk assessment to justify.

InsightRead