Technical scores written after the prices are known have a way of drifting toward the cheapest bid.
That is why a cleanroom HVAC package is better evaluated in two envelopes. The technical envelope is opened, scored and signed off first. Only then does anyone see a price.
The scoring sheet should exist before the bids arrive, and it should go out with the tender so bidders know what counts. It has two parts.
The first part is mandatory items, pass or fail: AHU casing classes to EN 1886 as specified, filter classes to EN 1822 and ISO 16890, a witnessed FAT against the approved datasheet, and an equipment file with material certificates. A bid that fails one of these is out, whatever it costs.
The second part weights everything else. One workable split puts 40% on technical depth (fan selection and efficiency, coil selection at the design dew point, controls) and 20% each on documentation and qualification support, on the delivery and installation plan, and on service and spares in the region. Each criterion gets a written scale, so two evaluators scoring the same bid land close together.
Read the bidder's deviation list line by line and score it. A "complies with minor deviations" often hides the dew point.
Humiley's project management work covers the design-to-procurement handover, which is where this sheet gets written against the design basis.
Topics



