Skip to content

Life Sciences

Plate exchanger or run-around coil for GMP heat recovery

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

EU ecodesign sets a 73% minimum thermal efficiency for most heat recovery and 68% for run-around coils, so on paper the plate wins.

Once a GMP exhaust stream has been cleared for recovery and the choice is a counterflow plate or a run-around coil, that gap is the number people quote. The figures are the 2018 tier of Regulation (EU) 1253/2014 for non-residential ventilation units; check the version in force when you buy. The plate moves heat straight from one airstream to the other, where the coil passes it through two coils and a glycol loop.

In a humid climate the plate's fresh-air side also runs wet. Its channels are a few millimetres wide, hard to inspect and harder to clean, and they sit in the fresh-air path of a GMP supply. A run-around coil gets wet too, but it can be opened up, cleaned and drained over its own drain pan like any other coil in the unit.

Fan and pump power need their own sum. A plate puts its resistance into both airstreams, so both fans pay for it; a run-around coil adds one coil to each unit and a pump that runs whenever recovery does. Compare total kW, not efficiency alone. And a run-around loop is only two pipes, so the exhaust fan can sit on the roof with the supply AHU two floors down, where a plate needs both airstreams at one casing.

Talk to an engineer about your exhaust streams: contact@humiley.com · +84 28 7777 6668 (Viet Nam office)

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Manufacturing & Distribution

Plug fan or belt drive in a GMP supply AHU

A V-belt sheds rubber dust into the airstream for its whole life, and in a GMP supply AHU that dust loads the final filters. Belt drives also lose a few per cent of shaft power and need regular tensioning. Direct-drive plug fans avoid all three, though a large belt-driven housed fan can still win at high pressure.

InsightRead