Skip to content

Life Sciences

RABS or isolator: the choice that sets your background grade

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

The barrier decision is often left to the filling line vendor.

It should be made with the HVAC engineer in the room, because it sets the background grade.

Under EU GMP Annex 1 (2022), a RABS used for aseptic processing sits in at least a Grade B background. A closed isolator can sit in Grade D, and an open isolator generally in at least Grade C, with the choice supported by risk assessment.

That one decision changes a lot downstream:

  1. HVAC. A Grade B background means the whole room must meet ISO 5 at rest, with more supply air, a steeper cascade and more airlocks. A Grade D background is a far smaller air handling system.
  2. Gowning. Grade B means full aseptic gowning and its own change rooms. Grade C or D gowning is simpler and faster.
  3. Operations. An isolator needs a validated biodecontamination cycle, typically vaporised hydrogen peroxide, and glove integrity testing, and changeovers take longer. A RABS is more flexible, but every door opening is an intervention to justify and record.
  4. Running cost. The smaller the Grade B envelope, the lower the energy bill for the life of the plant.

Neither is always right. A low-volume, multi-product line can favour RABS; high-potency products usually push towards an isolator.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

The scope of EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) says some of its principles, including the contamination control strategy, may be used for certain non-sterile products such as liquids, creams and ointments. A semi-solids plant that writes a CCS tying room grades, flows, water and monitoring to product risk has an answer for the inspector.

InsightRead

EU GMP Chapter 3 and 21 CFR 211 on HVAC

21 CFR 211.42 and 211.46 and EU GMP Chapter 3 ask for adequate ventilation, air control and filtration, but give no air change rate or pressure differential, and no filter class beyond HEPA for aseptic areas. Those come from Annex 1, FDA's 2004 aseptic guidance, ISO 14644 and the designer's justification, recorded in the design basis.

InsightRead