Skip to content

Life Sciences

30% of what? Fix the baseline first

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

A 30% HVAC energy saving means nothing until someone writes down 30% of what.

Energy percentages are easy to produce and hard to check. Two models run and the difference goes into the report. Change one assumption between the two models and the saving can grow or vanish with no equipment changing.

Before a percentage is worth quoting, these should be fixed in writing and held identical in both models:

  1. Room limits and GMP conditions. Same temperature, RH and pressure regime per room, taken from the room data sheets.
  2. The weather file. Same location and same design year. In the tropics a drier file mainly flatters the dehumidification load, which is where much of the energy goes.
  3. Production and cleaning schedules. Same operating hours, same night setback rules, same cleaning shifts.
  4. The airflow justification. Same air change rates and fresh-air quantities, unless the reduction itself is the measure being claimed and is argued separately.
  5. The baseline system, defined in a document. ASHRAE 90.1 Appendix G is one published method for this, and it removes the temptation to compare against an imaginary worst case.

With those five on one page, a QA head and a finance manager can check the figure themselves.

Humiley's energy modeling targets a 30% reduction in HVAC energy. Hold that figure to the same five points.

What did the baseline in your last energy report assume?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

EU GMP Chapter 3 and 21 CFR 211 on HVAC

21 CFR 211.42 and 211.46 and EU GMP Chapter 3 ask for adequate ventilation, air control and filtration, but give no air change rate or pressure differential, and no filter class beyond HEPA for aseptic areas. Those come from Annex 1, FDA's 2004 aseptic guidance, ISO 14644 and the designer's justification, recorded in the design basis.

InsightRead