Skip to content

Life Sciences

A vendor IQ/OQ protocol and the URS lines it leaves out

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

A bought-in IQ/OQ protocol can be executed and signed in two days without one of its tests citing a line of your URS.

It was written for the machine family, before your URS existed. It checks the standard machine: inputs and outputs, standard alarms, factory recipes. The vendor knows those tests best, and rewriting them in-house adds nothing.

EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) covers this in its section on documentation. Where validation protocols are supplied by a third party providing validation services, appropriate personnel at the manufacturing site should confirm suitability and compliance with internal procedures before approval, and vendor protocols may be supplemented by additional documentation or test protocols before use.

To confirm suitability, put the URS beside the protocol and write, against each URS line, the test that covers it. The lines left without a test are usually the site's own: the product's operating range, the site's alarm limits, the link to the BMS, access levels. Those go into a short supplementary protocol.

Read the acceptance criteria too. The vendor's criterion may be what the machine can do, which is sometimes wider than the process needs.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Annex 11 supplier assessment belongs in the validation plan

EU GMP Annex 11 clause 3.2 makes supplier competence and reliability part of computerized system validation, with the need for an audit set by risk. For SCADA, BMS and EMS, supplier records can reduce the testing the user repeats; the URS, risk assessment and configuration tests such as alarm limits and user roles stay with the user.

InsightRead