Skip to content

News

Clash tolerance, insulation and the test matrix

  • News
  • 1 min read

A duct running 40 mm into a beam drops out of a clash report whose tolerance is set at 50 mm.

That is what tolerance does in most clash software: interferences smaller than the value are ignored. It is there to hide noise, such as a pipe touching its own fitting. Set once at kickoff and never looked at again, it hides real problems as well.

Insulation catches out more reports than tolerance does. Chilled-water pipes and supply ducts are often modelled at their bare size, so the test passes and the site later finds no room for the lagging that has to go round them. The fix is to model the insulation as part of the element, or to run a clearance test with the insulation thickness as the clearance.

Then there is the question of which pairs were tested at all. The software checks only the combinations it is given. HVAC against structure always gets run. Sprinklers against ducts often do not, because the sprinkler model arrives late, and ducts against ducts inside the HVAC model get skipped because it is one discipline's file. Hangers nobody has modelled yet need a band reserved above the duct, or the rods reach site with nowhere to go.

A report that says zero clashes should state its tolerance, the pairs run and what each model leaves out, so the person receiving it can check the claim.

Our design is BIM-coordinated across HVAC, utilities and power.

Related

More on this subject

Compare deliverable lists before you compare totals

Two engineering proposals with similar totals can cover very different scopes. Before comparing prices, check that each deliverable list names Room Data Sheets, the pressure cascade and airflow balance, the URS and qualification protocols, the FAT and equipment file, and an asset register behind maintenance response times.

InsightRead

Comparing chiller offers on part-load efficiency

AHRI's IPLV gives full-load efficiency a 1% weight, yet chiller offers lead with full-load COP. A 24/7 GMP plant in Viet Nam spends much of the year at part load, with condenser water warmer than the rating assumes. Ask for efficiency at each load point at your real condenser temperature.

InsightRead