Skip to content

Life Sciences

Comparing chiller offers on part-load efficiency

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

AHRI's IPLV gives a chiller's full-load efficiency a weight of 1%. Full-load COP is still the number most offers put first.

A GMP plant in Viet Nam runs its chillers 24 hours a day, all year, and very few of those hours are at design load. The design day is rare, production shifts end, and chillers are staged with spare capacity for redundancy. Much of the year the machines sit somewhere between 25% and 75% load, which is where compressor type, variable-speed drives and heat-exchanger size show up.

IPLV (AHRI 550/590) and ESEER, the older Eurovent index now largely replaced by SEER to EN 14825, each fold efficiency at 100%, 75%, 50% and 25% load into one figure with fixed weights. Useful for comparing, with two cautions.

The weights were derived from typical commercial building loads, not from a plant that never switches off.

The rating also assumes condenser water gets colder as load falls. Where the wet-bulb hardly drops at night or in the dry season, the cooling tower cannot give that relief, so the rated part-load figure flatters the machine.

Ask instead for efficiency at each of the four load points, at condenser water temperatures your towers can actually produce, then weight them with the hours from your own load model.

Chiller selection is part of Humiley's energy modeling, which targets a 30% reduction in HVAC energy.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

EU GMP Chapter 3 and 21 CFR 211 on HVAC

21 CFR 211.42 and 211.46 and EU GMP Chapter 3 ask for adequate ventilation, air control and filtration, but give no air change rate or pressure differential, and no filter class beyond HEPA for aseptic areas. Those come from Annex 1, FDA's 2004 aseptic guidance, ISO 14644 and the designer's justification, recorded in the design basis.

InsightRead

Evidence you can hand to an inspector

A passed test that cannot be traced to a requirement is a common qualification gap. Linking each URS line to its calculation, drawing and test protocol in one traceability matrix, built from the first design issue, turns an inspector's question into a row number instead of a meeting.

InsightRead