Skip to content

Life Sciences

Design qualification: tracing every URS line at a stated revision

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

Signed design review minutes are often filed where the DQ report should be.

EU GMP Annex 15 (2015), section 3, is short on this. Compliance of the design with GMP should be demonstrated and documented, and the requirements of the user requirements specification should be verified during design qualification.

Minutes record who attended and what was discussed. Take one URS line: a room held at 15 Pa above the corridor. Verifying it means checking the pressure cascade drawing, the supply and extract airflows on the AHU schedule, and the door and damper leakage assumed behind the 15 Pa, and recording which revisions were checked, by whom. Minutes rarely carry that.

A DQ report that meets section 3 usually looks dull:

  1. Every URS requirement listed with its number.
  2. For each, the document that answers it (drawing, calculation, datasheet or specification clause) with its revision.
  3. A verdict, met, not met or met with a justified deviation, and the reviewer's signature.
  4. Open items assigned to a named owner with a date, before the design is frozen.

The revision column is where auditors dig. If the cascade drawing is rev C in the DQ and rev E in the IQ package, someone will ask what changed and whether the 15 Pa was checked again.

We write the URS and the validation strategy in parallel with the design, so the traceability matrix grows with the drawings.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Taking over a facility: start with a written gap assessment

Before changing an inherited facility or design, a written gap assessment against the URS and target regulations gives management and inspectors the same picture: evidence from documents and spot measurements, findings graded by risk, and the fix, cost range and schedule impact of each, plus what can stay.

InsightRead

Both states are required; only the stage is a choice

A 50 m² Grade B room needs 10 classification locations under ISO 14644-1:2015, and EU GMP Annex 1 requires them at rest against ISO 5 and in operation against ISO 7, with the smoke study in both states. Whether each run sits in OQ or PQ is for the URS and risk assessment to justify.

InsightRead