Skip to content

Manufacturing & Distribution

FAT vs SAT: what the factory test should hand to site

  • Manufacturing & Distribution
  • 1 min read

Most of what a SAT measures on an AHU does not exist at the factory.

Duct leakage, the balance of the pressure cascade, controller tuning against the real BMS, room recovery after a door opens: all of it waits until the unit is connected on site. A FAT can still make each of those site tests quicker if it records the right baselines. Four we would want in hand before SAT starts:

  1. Clean pressure drop across each filter stage and the coil at design airflow. Site uses it to set filter alarm points and to judge later readings.
  2. The factory casing leakage result. If the installed system fails its leakage test, this tells the team whether to open up the unit or start on the duct joints.
  3. Fan airflow and speed at the design external static pressure, so the balancing engineer starts from a measured point on the fan curve rather than the catalogue.
  4. The panel software version and I/O list as tested. When the BMS integrator maps points, both sides work from the same revision.

Getting these mostly means drafting the FAT protocol with the SAT protocol open beside it.

On our EPCM projects FAT, SAT and commissioning sit in one scope, and every unit we supply is FAT-tested and witnessed.

Related

More on this subject

Four checks at the basic-design gate

Before detail design opens, a GMP project should have frozen room data sheets and pressure cascade, loads that match the equipment list, a URS for each critical system and owned open items. A cascade change after the ducts are drawn reaches the duct sizes, terminal filters, AHU selection and every neighbouring pressure step.

InsightRead

Hold cleanroom pressure on the extract side

A cleanroom is qualified on its supply airflow: air change rate, recovery time and hood velocity. Controlling room pressure by trimming supply moves those numbers with every door opening. Holding supply constant and modulating extract or return keeps the qualified airflow and still holds the pressure cascade.

InsightRead