Many change control procedures send a like-for-like filter gauge swap through the same FMEA template as a change to Grade A airflow.
Trivial changes collect forty-line FMEAs written to be finished and never read, while the change that deserved engineering, QA and production in one room gets the same form filled in thinly.
ICH Q9(R1), adopted in January 2023, added guidance on the degree of formality in quality risk management. Formality should rise with uncertainty, importance and complexity, and a lighter approach is legitimate when the risk is well understood. The revision also added a section on subjectivity: scoring scales that two people read differently produce numbers that look precise and are not.
A procedure can use that directly by writing down what moves a change to a full FMEA. Touching airflow, the pressure regime or the critical zone is the obvious trigger. Uncertainty is another one, such as a change nobody on site has made before. For work that hits none of them, a documented rationale in the change control record, or a short assessment by the owner and QA, is enough.
Then anchor each score with an example from your own plant, so a "4" for detectability means the same thing to the engineer and to QA. On the EPCM projects we run, the FMEA risk register is live and reviewed weekly; the review stays short only when a score means the same to everyone in the room.
Topics
Industries




