Skip to content

Project Management Consultancy

When a GMP project needs Monte Carlo on its program

  • Project Management Consultancy
  • 1 min read

An 80% chance on each of two independent long-lead paths is a 64% chance that both arrive when qualification needs them.

That is merge bias, and a qualitative risk register cannot show it. The FMEA register lists what might go wrong, scores it and gives each risk an owner. It suits week-to-week risk management. It cannot add risks up along the program and tell you how likely the finish date is.

A quantitative schedule risk analysis does that. Each activity on the critical and near-critical paths gets a three-point duration estimate. A Monte Carlo simulation runs the program thousands of times and returns a distribution: the date with a 50% chance of being met, the date at 80%, and which activities drive the spread.

Most GMP projects do not need it at every stage. It earns its cost when:

  1. Several long-lead paths (AHUs, clean utility skids, MCCs) converge on one qualification start.
  2. The finish date is tied to something that will not move, such as a booked inspection or a registration filing.
  3. Liquidated damages or a product launch sit behind the date.

The inputs are the hard part. Three-point estimates have to come from the people who own the work, not from the scheduler alone, or the simulation reproduces the plan's optimism with more decimals.

In our EPCM work the FMEA register is reviewed weekly and reported monthly beside schedule, cost and earned value.

Which date does your board see, P50 or P80?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Four checks at the basic-design gate

Before detail design opens, a GMP project should have frozen room data sheets and pressure cascade, loads that match the equipment list, a URS for each critical system and owned open items. A cascade change after the ducts are drawn reaches the duct sizes, terminal filters, AHU selection and every neighbouring pressure step.

InsightRead

GMP on the electrical side

Where a SCADA, BMS or EMS records GMP-relevant data, access control, clock synchronization, alarm records and audit trails are decided by the electrical and automation engineers. Many sites keep those parameters on a separate validated EMS. Humiley's cross-functional training covers GMP, validation and project management.

InsightRead

Grade B at rest: state the equipment condition

Grade B at rest is held to 3,520 particles ≥0.5 µm and 29 ≥5 µm per m³. Annex 1 (2022) defines at rest for GMP grades as HVAC running, main equipment installed and standing by, and no personnel, reached after a clean-up period of under 20 minutes as guidance. The protocol should record that condition.

InsightRead