Skip to content

Engineering Solution & Consultancy

The stage-gate criterion most often waived: re-running the estimate

  • Engineering Solution & Consultancy
  • 1 min read

The estimate presented at a basic-design gate is sometimes the concept estimate with a new date on the cover.

Take a Grade C area that grows from 800 m² at concept to 950 m² at basic design, because the process team added a second wash room and a wider airlock. Carry the estimate forward and the HVAC, the wall panels and the ceiling are still priced on 800 m². That is 19% more cleanroom than the budget covers, and it tends to surface when the detail design goes out to tender.

On a GMP project each gate releases money for the next stage, which makes it the last cheap place to catch a gap like that. The gate can only hold the money if its criteria were on paper before the meeting. We ask for five:

  1. The design basis is frozen for this stage, including the destination market (EU, WHO or US).
  2. URS lines due now are answered and traced to a calculation or drawing.
  3. The estimate is re-run on current quantities.
  4. Each open risk in the FMEA register has an owner and a date.
  5. The schedule to the next gate can be staffed by the design team as it stands.

Item 3 is the easy one to waive. Re-running an estimate takes a week and the gate meeting is on Thursday. Waived with a condition attached, it tends to come back as a change order during construction.

Our EPCM team runs stage-gate delivery from concept to PQ, with earned value reporting and a weekly FMEA review.

Which gate criterion does your team waive most often?

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Manufacturing & Distribution

Two envelopes for a cleanroom HVAC tender

Score the technical envelope of a cleanroom HVAC tender and sign it off before any price is opened. Issue the scoring sheet with the tender: mandatory items pass or fail, the rest weighted, for example 40% technical depth and 20% each for documentation, delivery and service. Score every listed deviation.

InsightRead

Annex 1's scope reaches non-sterile plants

The scope of EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) says some of its principles, including the contamination control strategy, may be used for certain non-sterile products such as liquids, creams and ointments. A semi-solids plant that writes a CCS tying room grades, flows, water and monitoring to product risk has an answer for the inspector.

InsightRead

Energy savings and the requalification bill

Energy measures that change validated cleanroom conditions go through Annex 15 change control. Classification alone can mean 10 sample locations for a 50 m² room, at rest and in operation, before recovery tests and a CCS update. Price that next to the kWh, or design reduced modes in and qualify them once.

InsightRead