The estimate presented at a basic-design gate is sometimes the concept estimate with a new date on the cover.
Take a Grade C area that grows from 800 m² at concept to 950 m² at basic design, because the process team added a second wash room and a wider airlock. Carry the estimate forward and the HVAC, the wall panels and the ceiling are still priced on 800 m². That is 19% more cleanroom than the budget covers, and it tends to surface when the detail design goes out to tender.
On a GMP project each gate releases money for the next stage, which makes it the last cheap place to catch a gap like that. The gate can only hold the money if its criteria were on paper before the meeting. We ask for five:
- The design basis is frozen for this stage, including the destination market (EU, WHO or US).
- URS lines due now are answered and traced to a calculation or drawing.
- The estimate is re-run on current quantities.
- Each open risk in the FMEA register has an owner and a date.
- The schedule to the next gate can be staffed by the design team as it stands.
Item 3 is the easy one to waive. Re-running an estimate takes a week and the gate meeting is on Thursday. Waived with a condition attached, it tends to come back as a change order during construction.
Our EPCM team runs stage-gate delivery from concept to PQ, with earned value reporting and a weekly FMEA review.
Which gate criterion does your team waive most often?
Industries



