Skip to content

News

What a few points of motor efficiency are worth

  • News
  • 1 min read

A 7.5 kW fan shaft load running 8,760 hours a year takes about 2,350 kWh more at 90% motor efficiency than at 93%.

The arithmetic is short. At 90%, the motor draws 7.5 / 0.90 = 8.33 kW. At 93%, 7.5 / 0.93 = 8.06 kW. The difference is about 0.27 kW, and a cleanroom supply fan does not stop at night or at weekends. Over a year that is roughly 2,350 kWh from one motor. Multiply by your tariff and by the number of fans on site.

A gap of a couple of points is typical between neighbouring IEC 60034-30-1 classes at this size, IE3 to IE4. The class tables give minimum nominal efficiencies by power and pole count; look up the real figures before they go into a business case. EC motors are often offered at IE4 or IE5 level, and their drive losses have to be counted too.

Two cautions. The class is rated at full load, and many cleanroom fans run well below it, where different motor types lose efficiency differently. So ask the vendor for the tested motor-plus-drive efficiency at your duty point, not the class on the nameplate. And the gain only counts where the hours are real: an exhaust fan that runs one shift gets about a third of it.

Humiley's AHU selection platform has an ErP compliance module, which puts fan and motor efficiency on the table during selection.

More engineering notes

Related

More on this subject

Why qualified rooms stay constant volume

A classified room's air change rate, recovery time and pressure steps were proved at one airflow. Constant volume holds each room's flow at that value with a terminal, while the fan speeds up as filters load. VAV moves supply with the cooling load, so it belongs in offices, technical areas and fume-hood exhaust.

InsightRead

A retention that pays for the turnover file

Most of a cleanroom HVAC contract is paid before the turnover documents exist. Split the retention into two parts, released on acceptance of the turnover package and of the documents, and size the documentation part on what it would cost the owner to finish as-builts, calibrations and retests without the contractor.

InsightRead