Skip to content

News

Harmonic studies need the generator case

  • News
  • 1 min read

An EC fan wall that looks acceptable on grid supply can distort the voltage far more when the site switches to its standby generator.

The reason is Ohm's law, applied one harmonic at a time. Voltage distortion is harmonic current multiplied by the source impedance at that frequency. The fan wall draws the same 5th, 7th, 11th and 13th harmonic currents whichever source feeds it. What changes is the impedance behind the busbar.

A distribution transformer is a stiff source, typically 4–6% impedance. A diesel generator's subtransient reactance X''d is typically 12–20% on its own rating, and the generator is often smaller in kVA than the transformer it backs up, which raises the impedance further once both are on the same base. The voltage distortion scales with it. Controls, UPS rectifiers and the generator's own voltage regulator are usually the first to notice.

In a GMP plant the standby case is not a rare event. It is the case that keeps the cleanroom pressurised through an outage, so the HVAC has to run on it cleanly.

The harmonic study should model both sources. IEEE 519-2022 sets current-distortion (TDD) limits at the utility point of common coupling, scaled by the site's short-circuit ratio. On generator there is no utility PCC, but the generator busbar still needs a voltage distortion limit, a calculation and a check during commissioning.

Does your harmonic study include the generator case, or only the grid?

Related

More on this subject

Two envelopes for a cleanroom HVAC tender

Score the technical envelope of a cleanroom HVAC tender and sign it off before any price is opened. Issue the scoring sheet with the tender: mandatory items pass or fail, the rest weighted, for example 40% technical depth and 20% each for documentation, delivery and service. Score every listed deviation.

InsightRead

A retention that pays for the turnover file

Most of a cleanroom HVAC contract is paid before the turnover documents exist. Split the retention into two parts, released on acceptance of the turnover package and of the documents, and size the documentation part on what it would cost the owner to finish as-builts, calibrations and retests without the contractor.

InsightRead

As-built classification on a new cleanroom suite

ISO 14644-1 allows a room to be classified as-built: installation complete, services running, no equipment, materials or people. On a new suite it shows whether the HVAC, filters and envelope can reach the class alone. It says nothing about machines or people, so the GMP classification is still done at rest and in operation.

InsightRead