Skip to content

Project Management Consultancy

A retention that pays for the turnover file

  • Project Management Consultancy
  • 1 min read

Most of a cleanroom HVAC contract has been paid before its turnover documents exist.

By the time the package is balanced and running, what remains open is the file: as-built drawings, commissioning and balancing records, calibration certificates, O&M manuals, and the punch items that block qualification. If the retention is a flat percentage released at practical completion, a contractor can leave that file thin and still be paid in full.

Three changes to the contract help:

  1. Split the retention into 2 parts, each with its own trigger. One is released when the turnover package is accepted, with every punch item that blocks qualification closed and verified. The other is released when the documents have been reviewed and accepted, which is later than the day they are delivered.
  2. Size the documentation part on what it would cost the owner to finish the job without the contractor. Price it: as-builts redrawn from a site survey, calibrations repeated, a re-balance and a repeat of the affected tests. If the sum held is smaller than that, walking away from the paperwork is the cheaper option for the contractor, and some will take it.
  3. Release per system package, not per building, so a finished AHU system is paid when it is finished.

On our EPCM projects, systems are commissioned, balanced and turned over package by package, each with its own evidence.

Talk to an engineer: contact@humiley.com · +84 28 7777 6668 (Viet Nam office)

Related

More on this subject

Two envelopes for a cleanroom HVAC tender

Score the technical envelope of a cleanroom HVAC tender and sign it off before any price is opened. Issue the scoring sheet with the tender: mandatory items pass or fail, the rest weighted, for example 40% technical depth and 20% each for documentation, delivery and service. Score every listed deviation.

InsightRead

Grade B at rest: state the equipment condition

Grade B at rest is held to 3,520 particles ≥0.5 µm and 29 ≥5 µm per m³. Annex 1 (2022) defines at rest for GMP grades as HVAC running, main equipment installed and standing by, and no personnel, reached after a clean-up period of under 20 minutes as guidance. The protocol should record that condition.

InsightRead

Value engineering after tender: savings that return at OQ

After an over-budget cleanroom HVAC tender, three savings recur: an EN 1886 L2 casing instead of L1, fewer room pressure transmitters, and deleted door drop-seals. Each can reappear as an OQ failure in airflow, alarm testing or pressure differentials, so check every line against its URS requirement and test before accepting it.

InsightRead