Skip to content

News

ALCOA+ on the EMS is a design requirement

  • News
  • 1 min read

02:14, night shift. A Grade B pressure alarm is acknowledged under the login "operator". Nobody can say who that was.

That one line is a data integrity finding. EMS and BMS data that support GMP decisions have to meet ALCOA+: attributable, legible, contemporaneous, original and accurate, plus complete, consistent, enduring and available. On a facility system those words become design requirements:

  1. Attributable: individual user accounts with role-based access. No shared "operator" or "admin" logins.
  2. Contemporaneous: controllers and servers time-synchronized, so an alarm on the PLC and its record on the server carry the same time.
  3. Original and complete: an audit trail that records who changed a setpoint or alarm limit, from what, to what, when and why, and that users cannot switch off.
  4. Alarms treated as records: acknowledgement with user, time and comment, and alarm delays that are justified rather than left at default.
  5. Enduring and available: backups with a tested restore, and retention that matches your record-keeping rules.

Decide early which parameters are GMP-critical. Those belong on a validated EMS; the rest can stay on the BMS without dragging it into full Part 11 and Annex 11 validation.

Humiley designs automation and SCADA to 21 CFR Part 11 and EU Annex 11 on Rockwell, AVEVA, COPA-DATA and Ignition platforms.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Part 11 or Annex 11: fix the destination market on day one

21 CFR Part 11 and EU GMP Annex 11 overlap on validation, access control and audit trails but differ in emphasis: Part 11 on electronic signatures, Annex 11 on a risk-based system lifecycle. Fixing the destination market in the design basis means the URS and validation plan for BMS, EMS and SCADA are written once.

Read

Backup and archive are two controls under Annex 11

EU GMP Annex 11 clause 7.2 asks for regular backups whose restore is checked during validation and periodically. Clause 17 asks that archived data stays accessible, readable and intact, with retrieval re-tested after system changes. A green nightly backup does not prove that old trend data opens after an upgrade.

InsightRead

GAMP 5 software categories are 1, 3, 4 and 5; firmware stopped being Category 2 in 2008. Validation effort rises with each step, and a configured Category 4 SCADA can still hold Category 5 scripts that need custom-code testing. The 2022 Second Edition kept the categories.

InsightRead