Validated to assay the active in a tablet, a method has shown nothing about finding traces of that active on a swab.
ICH Q2(R2), adopted in November 2023, sets one objective for validation: to demonstrate that the analytical procedure is fit for the intended purpose. "The method is validated" means validated for one purpose, which is narrower than it sounds in a project meeting.
Table 1 of the guideline lists what a validation study typically demonstrates. Specificity, or selectivity, means the result is not disturbed by anything else in the sample: excipients, degradation products, or whatever the swab picked up from the surface. The range is the interval in which the procedure has a suitable response, accuracy and precision, and for an impurity or a residue its bottom end is what counts, stated as a quantitation limit or a detection limit. Accuracy and precision are shown across that range: results close to the true value, and repeats that agree across days, analysts and equipment.
Robustness is typically evaluated earlier, during development under ICH Q14.
EU GMP Annex 15 (2015) says analytical test methods used in qualification, validation or cleaning exercises should be validated with an appropriate detection and quantification limit, where necessary. When a swab result on a project is disputed, start by asking which sample and which level the method was validated for.
Topics
Industries




