A swab from the flat stainless panel at eye level passes every time. That is the reason to doubt a plan built on such points.
Cleaning validation is meant to show that the procedure works where it is most likely to fail. Section 10 of EU GMP Annex 15, in its 2015 text, says the protocol should specify or reference the locations to be sampled and the rationale for selecting them, and that recovery should be shown to be possible from all product contact materials sampled, with all the sampling methods used.
Read the list of swab locations in the protocol against these points.
- Hard-to-clean points are on it: valve seats, gasket grooves, dead ends, the underside of an agitator blade.
- So are accumulation points: discharge chutes, filter housings.
- Every product-contact material appears at least once: stainless steel, PTFE, silicone, glass.
- Each location has one written line of rationale and is marked on a drawing or photograph.
- The swab area is defined, usually with a template, and a recovery study exists for each material with the swab and solvent actually used.
Some of the worst locations cannot be reached with a swab at all. Those are cases for rinse sampling or for dismantling, and the plan should say which.
A short list with a written reason for each location is easier to defend than a long one chosen for convenience.
Topics
Industries




