Skip to content

Life Sciences

10–15 Pa for FDA, 10 Pa for Annex 1: one cascade

  • Life Sciences
  • 1 min read

FDA's 2004 aseptic processing guidance asks for at least 10–15 Pa between adjacent rooms of different classification, doors closed.

Annex 1 gives 10 Pa as a minimum guidance value. One design can meet both.

The two documents arrive at nearly the same number from different directions. The FDA guidance states it as 10–15 Pa, or 0.04–0.06 inches of water. EU GMP Annex 1 says adjacent rooms of different grades should have a differential of at least 10 Pa, as a guidance value, and expects the differentials to be monitored with alarms. For a plant that ships to both markets, setting each step of the cascade at 15 Pa sits inside both texts.

The harder part is holding it. A cascade balanced at 15 Pa at commissioning can read 8 Pa a year later if door seals wear, ceiling tiles are lifted and not resealed, or filters load and the supply fan runs out of margin. None of that shows on the day of the OQ.

So the design needs margin, and the monitoring needs to trend. A differential that slides over months is visible in the trend long before it trips an alarm, and that is when it is cheap to fix.

We fix the destination market in the design basis on day one, so the cascade is set for the evidence the plant will have to produce.

Industries

Related

More on this subject

Annex 1's scope reaches non-sterile plants

The scope of EU GMP Annex 1 (2022) says some of its principles, including the contamination control strategy, may be used for certain non-sterile products such as liquids, creams and ointments. A semi-solids plant that writes a CCS tying room grades, flows, water and monitoring to product risk has an answer for the inspector.

InsightRead

ASTM E2500: who verifies, and whose documents count

Two ideas in ASTM E2500 shorten qualification. Subject matter experts plan, execute and review verification, and in ISPE's summary of the 2025 edition the quality unit approves the plans and the final acceptance. Vendor documentation may be used as evidence if the vendor has been assessed. EU GMP Annex 15 (2015 text) allows some FAT tests to stand at IQ/OQ where justified.

InsightRead

Both states are required; only the stage is a choice

A 50 m² Grade B room needs 10 classification locations under ISO 14644-1:2015, and EU GMP Annex 1 requires them at rest against ISO 5 and in operation against ISO 7, with the smoke study in both states. Whether each run sits in OQ or PQ is for the URS and risk assessment to justify.

InsightRead