Skip to content

News

Air change rate: a useful check, a poor requirement

  • News
  • 1 min read

A URS that asks for "20 air changes per hour" has written down the answer before anyone did the sum.

Air changes per hour is supply airflow divided by room volume. A 120 m³ room supplied with 2,400 m³/h runs at 20 ACH. The figure is real, but it is an output of the design, and the requirements that should produce it sit elsewhere:

  1. The cleanliness class the room must hold, at rest and in operation.
  2. The heat the room must lose: process equipment, lighting, people.
  3. How fast it must recover after a disturbance: a 100:1 recovery time to ISO 14644-3, stated in the URS with the method. (Annex 1's clean-up period, guidance under 20 minutes, is a separate figure set during qualification.)

Work those out and the airflow is whichever of them asks for the most. Sometimes that is cleanliness. In a room with a hot process it is often the heat load, and the ACH that results has nothing to do with the rule of thumb in the URS.

Written as the requirement, ACH does damage both ways. Rooms with light loads get more air than they need, and the fan energy is paid every hour of the plant's life. Rooms with heavy loads meet the ACH on paper and still fail on temperature or recovery.

Keep ACH as a sanity check on the airflow schedule. Put the class, the heat load and the recovery time in the URS, and prove them the way qualification does: particle counts and a recovery test.

Related

More on this subject

Both states are required; only the stage is a choice

A 50 m² Grade B room needs 10 classification locations under ISO 14644-1:2015, and EU GMP Annex 1 requires them at rest against ISO 5 and in operation against ISO 7, with the smoke study in both states. Whether each run sits in OQ or PQ is for the URS and risk assessment to justify.

InsightRead

Grade B at rest: state the equipment condition

Grade B at rest is held to 3,520 particles ≥0.5 µm and 29 ≥5 µm per m³. Annex 1 (2022) defines at rest for GMP grades as HVAC running, main equipment installed and standing by, and no personnel, reached after a clean-up period of under 20 minutes as guidance. The protocol should record that condition.

InsightRead

Recovery test or clean-up period in the URS

The ISO 14644-3 recovery test times a 100:1 fall in particle concentration after an aerosol challenge and measures the air system. The Annex 1 clean-up period, under 20 minutes as a guidance value and set during qualification, describes the room after real operations. Write the recovery test into the URS and set the clean-up period at in-operation qualification.

InsightRead